Orion
Grand Member
Posts: 463
|
Post by Orion on Feb 2, 2005 2:02:20 GMT
In this thread, post your opinion on the individual game of a player, meaning how they rank (as in top 50, top 20, top 10, 5, 4, 3, 2, 1) on the active list of players in the top 100-200 or so in several different categories, in your opinion. and discuss.
The categories (feel free to add more if I neglected some...):
1: 1st Serve 2: 2nd Serve 3: Return of Serve 4: Forehand (overall) 4a: Running 4b: Forehand Drive 4c: Slice Forehand 5: Backhand (overall) 5a: Running 5b: Backhand Drive 5c: Slice Backhand 6: Volley (overall) 6a: Forehand Volley 6b: Backhand Volley 6c: Overhead Volley 7: Smash 8: Lob 9: Dropshot 10: Movement (overall) 10a: Speed 10b: Footwork
|
|
Orion
Grand Member
Posts: 463
|
Post by Orion on Feb 2, 2005 2:18:00 GMT
First I'll do my overall list of the top 5 in each category
1st Serve: 1: Serena Williams 2: Lindsay Davenport 3: Venus Williams 4: Alicia Molik 5: Maria Sharapova
2nd Serve: 1: Davenport 2: Molik 3: Nadia Petrova 4: Svetlana Kuznetsova 5: S. Williams
Return of Serve: 1: V. Williams 2: Kim Clijsters 3: Justine Henin-Hardenne 4: S. Williams 5: Jennifer Capriati
Forehand (overall): 1: S. Kuznetsova 2: Molik 3: Capriati 4: Elena Dementieva 5: Clijsters
Running Forehand: 1: Capriati 2: Molik (when she really runs for them...) 3: Kuznetsova 4: Amelie Mauresmo 5: Anastasia Myskina
Forehand Drive: 1: Kuznetsova 2: Dementieva 3: Molik 4: Clijsters 5: Capriati
Slice Forehand: 1: Molik 2: Kuznetsova 3: Clijsters 4: Conchita Martinez 5: Paola Suarez
Backhand (overall): 1: Mauresmo 2: Henin-Hardenne 3: Sivia Farina-Elia 4: Davenport 5: Dementieva
Running Backhand: 1: Henin-Hardenne 2: Farina-Elia 3: Dementieva 4: Myskina 5: Mauresmo
Backhand Drive: 1: Mauresmo 2: Dementieva 3: Davenport 4: Henin Hardenne 5: Farina-Elia
Slice Backhand: Top 5 1: Mauresmo (finest approaching shot in women's tennis) 2: Molik (very good approaching shot) 3: Davenport 4: Dementieva 5: Kuznetsova
Volley (overall): 1: Mauresmo 2: Patty Schnyder 3: S. Williams (unorthodox, but still useful) 4: V. Williams (if only she did it more) 5: Kuznetsova
Forehand Volley: 1: Schnyder 2: Kuznetsova 3: S. Williams 4: V. Williams 5: Mauresmo
Backhand Volley: 1: Mauresmo 2: Henin-Hardenne 3: Schnyder 4: Kuznetsova 5: Vera Zvonereva (very neat shot, but not as incredible as others)
Overhead Volley: 1: V. Williams 2: S. Williams 3: Mauresmo 4: Kuznetsova 5: Pierce (scares me when I see it)
Smash: 1: S. Williams 2: Myskina 3: Petrova 4: Mauresmo 5: V. Williams
Lob: 1: Clijsters (picked it up from Lleyton) 2: Maggie Maleeva 3: Schnyder 4: Zuluaga 5: Sharapova
Dropshot: 1: Schnyder 2: Mauresmo (the French simply have lovely skillshots) 3: Nathalie Dechy 4: Elena Bovina 5: Sharapova (it's developing very nicely since last year)
Movement (overall): 1: Myskina 2: Henin-Hardenne 3: Sharapova 4: S. Williams 5: Capriati
Speed: 1: S. Williams 2: Myskina 3: Sharapova 4: Kuznetsova 5: V. Williams
Footwork: 1: Henin-Hardenne 2: Sharapova 3: Myskina 4: Davenport (yes, I said it. Otherwise, she couldn't hit the ball well standing still!) 5: S. Williams (it's gotten soooo much better than it used to be)
|
|
Orion
Grand Member
Posts: 463
|
Post by Orion on Feb 2, 2005 2:54:29 GMT
I'll do Svetlana Kuznetsova, because I like her game a ton.
1st Serve: Top 10. It's not too fast, but she puts some movement on the ball.
2nd Serve: Top 5. This is the strength of her service game: it doesn't crumble under pressure.
Return of Serve: Top 10. It's not incredible, but it's solid enough to keep her in the game.
Forehand (overall): 1st
Running Forehand: 3rd, behind Capriati and Molik
Forehand Drive: 1st, barely ahead of Dementieva and Molik
Slice Forehand: 2nd, interesting shot that Molik is excellent at, changes the pace of the game well.
Backhand (overall): Top 20. If there is a weakness in Kuznetsova's game, it's the backhand. Other than the slice, she doesn't use it to great effect.
Running Backhand: Top 20
Backhand Drive: Top 20
Slice Backhand: Top 5
Volley (overall): 5th
Forehand Volley: 2nd
Backhand Volley: 4th
Overhead Volley: 5th
Smash: Top 10
Lob: Top 20. It's a skillshot Kuznetsova doesn't have a handle on quite yet.
Dropshot: Top 10. It can come from nowhere and surprise you, but not consistent enough yet
Movement (overall): Top 10
Speed: 4th. There's no denying, this girl is fast.
Footwork: Top 20. Not graceful. Reminds me a little of Serena when she was 18-20, she didn't take small steps. It worked without the small steps, but a few points at pivotal moments are determined by small steps.
|
|